Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts from October, 2026

How difficult was it in the past to start an old car using a crank handle? How could someone drive if they were too weak to crank it over?

Starting an early car wasn't just a test of brute strength—it routinely broke drivers' wrists. If you were too weak to risk a "Ford fracture," your best alternative was surprisingly modern. Before the electric starter became standard, drivers had to manually turn over the engine using a heavy metal crank at the front of the vehicle. The difficulty lay in fighting the engine's compression and the thick, sluggish motor oils of the era, which turned to molasses in cold weather. But the real danger was "kickback." If the engine's spark timing was set incorrectly, the fuel-air mixture could ignite too early, violently reversing the engine's rotation and ripping the iron handle backward. This backward snap was responsible for the broken wrists and snapped forearms that plagued early motorists. To minimize the risk, seasoned drivers learned to pull up on the crank in quick, sharp jerks rather than pushing down, and to keep their thumb tucked alongside t...

What are some ww1 cliches that are factually not true? Such as generals being incompetent and the war itself being a giant folly.

  "Lions led by donkeys" is a commonly used phrase to describe the “poor bloody infantry” of the British Expeditionary Force of World War One, and to blame the incompetent old generals who led them from the safety of their chateaux. In fact, during the war, 78 British and Dominion generals were killed on active duty, 146 others were injured, gassed, or captured. Of course, some generals were not up to the task, but it must remembered that the British generals were accustomed to small colonial wars. The British commanders (along with other armies) had to adjust to a more radically different technological environment. World War One popularized the use of the machine gun, able to shoot down row after row of soldiers from afar on the field of battle. This weapon, along with the barbed wire, artillery and mines, made it difficult and dangerous to move through the open ground. So the war in the trench was born. The British introduced tanks in 1916, which were used along with aircra...

What made Canadian troops particularly suited for the intense house-to-house battles during World War II?

  When street combat in WWII's "Little Stalingrad" became suicidal, Canadian troops took entire city blocks without ever stepping outside—by relying on their pre-war day jobs. The Battle of Ortona in late 1943 transformed the tight, ancient streets of an Italian coastal town into heavily fortified kill zones. Advancing down the roads was a death sentence, and Allied armored advantages were completely neutralized by deep rubble. To capture the town, the 1st Canadian Infantry Division had to invent a new way to fight. Regiments like the Loyal Edmonton Regiment and the Seaforth Highlanders of Canada were heavily drawn from the country's working-class and rural frontiers. As former miners, loggers, and construction workers, they possessed an innate comfort with physical hardship, a working knowledge of tools, and, crucially, a practical familiarity with explosives. When traditional tactics broke down in the rubble-choked streets, these soldiers adapted by pioneering a tec...

What did German soldiers really think about American combat tactics during World War II, and why did they find them problematic?

  Rommel is probably the best example as he fought the Americans both in Africa and in France. Rommel respected the American troops, and said that while they were green, they fought hard and learned fast. He liked the American kit and deeply respected American logistics, viewing it as the greatest challenge to overcome. He liked that Americans adapted quickly, saying that it was much easier to teach a new soldier something new rather than a veteran, and that while it was easier to trick the Americans than the British, it was harder to trick them multiple times. He criticized Americans cautiousness, lack of initiative, and over reliance on logistics. He believed that Americans lacked the initiative and tactical understanding of fast mechanized combat and contrasted them with his own emphasis on maneuver warfare, reconnaissance, concealment, and rapid exploitation of breakthroughs. Rommel had made a name for himself in France by ignoring logistics and making deep tank thrusts behind ...

If the USSR had decided to invade all of Europe in 1945, would the Allies have been able to defeat them without atomic power?

There’s a little known fact the Soviet Union lost 1–2 million people in 1946–47. Soviet famine of 1946-47 This really shouldn’t be too surprising, the USSR spent the better part of the last four years fighting the most brutal war in history and the Nazis occupied the bulk of best Soviet farmland. The mass mobilization and subsequent grotesque personnel losses also created an epic labor shortage, compounded by the absolutely massive military production. During the war there was American food coming in, but once this stopped the domestic production was nowhere near sufficient and people died as a result. USSR actually mobilized some 16-year olds into the Red Army in 1945. They were at the end of manpower, the only way they could replace losses were either child soldiers or mobilization of millions of factory laborers, which would leave them without industrial capacity to replace losses. Another bit of an issue that is frequently forgotten is that Ukraine, Baltics and Poland weren’t excac...

How common was it for soldiers in the Second World War to survive the entire war?

  Reasonably common, even for a front line soldier. My Dad, a Kiwi soldier, was away three years in North Africa, and one year in Italy. He and those like him did survive, but they were different men when they eventually arrived home. Because of distance, very few New Zealanders had leave at home, but had breaks in nearby towns and cities. They did not spend time with families, their only family were their mates. They ate every day in camp,”Bully Beef”, a fatty corned beef. My Mum was a NZ Nurse in the same locations, and the hospital provided the same, all bulk supplied fron New Zealand. Sometimes they got a tin of pears to share between two. Shared all the time with thousands of flies. Water came in 4 gallon tins, originally sent with petrol to North Africa, and was always slightly tainted. So they missed out on family love, famiiy meals, foods lovingly prepared. Their education stopped. Dad had just got through a degree in biology, before being called up. The food, flies and dir...

Was life better in England in the 1950s than today?

I was born in London in 1947. Finding accommodation in London after the war was close to impossible so my parents lived in my grandparents house. My mother’s wedding dress was made from white parachute silk and made by a neighbour. Fortunately my grandmother worked in a military store !!! My grandfather worked in the London docks and their rented house was very typical of a working family house at that time. A small terraced house with no bathroom so the kitchen was used for all washing other than a weekly bath in a tin bath on the floor. Their house early in the was was bombed so they just found an empty house nearby and moved in. It was some years before they found who owned it but my grandmother always saved money for rent so they could pay when the owner turned up - which they did eventually. Everyone shared the same water for the weekly bath as there was no built in hot water supply. It all had to be heated in pots on the gas stove. No bathroom meant the lavatory was a small room ...

When Tito broke with Stalin in 1948, why didn't Stalin attack Yugoslavia?

Stalin essentially had very few options with regard to Tito and realized early on that any attempts to reign in Yugoslavia by force were only going to hurt rather than help his cause. Joseph Broz Tito, ruler of Yugoslavia from 1941 to 1980 and archrival to the Man of Steel himself. At the end of World War 2, Yugoslavia held the distinction of being one of the few countries to actually give Germany a hard time in not just conquering, but occupying it. Tito had battle hardened and experienced partisan force at his disposal, a populace that was willing to die for him, and a knowledge of his own country that proved invaluable in partisan warfare. The Yugoslav Air Force was regarded as one of the best in the region at that time and the Yugoslav Army had years of experience in guerilla warfare and a home turf advantage. If Stalin was going to apply military force to Yugoslavia, he’d end up running into the same exact issues that the Germans had only much worse. The only reason that Poland an...

What if a soldier had bad diarrhea in the middle of a battle? Where would he go?

When bullets are snapping overhead, stopping to pull down your trousers is a death sentence. If severe diarrhea strikes during a firefight, a soldier simply soils themselves and keeps fighting. Survival overrides dignity. Infantry veterans widely acknowledge this unglamorous reality of warfare. A soiled uniform can be washed or burned later; a gunshot wound cannot be undone. Historically, diarrheal diseases like dysentery have been a greater threat to armies than enemy action. During the American Civil War, diarrhea and dysentery killed tens of thousands. In the muddy, static trenches of World War I, and the jungles of Vietnam, "the trots" were a constant, miserable companion. If a soldier could not safely reach a latrine or a designated corner of a trench, they had no choice but to let nature take its course where they stood. When combat lulls, the protocols change. During tactical pauses, soldiers might dig a quick "cat hole," while in longer defensive positions t...

Why did Henry Ford decide to switch to a five-day work week, and how did it impact other companies at the time?

  In 1926, Henry Ford gave his workers Saturdays off with full pay, prompting rivals to warn of moral decay. It wasn't charity—he was engineering a society that required his cars. Ford recognized that a worker spending six days a week on the factory floor and resting on Sunday had little opportunity to engage in the broader economy. He famously argued that leisure was "an indispensable ingredient in a growing consumer market." By introducing a two-day weekend, Ford gave his workforce a reason to purchase automobiles, take road trips, and buy consumer goods. The shift also solved a severe efficiency problem on the factory floor. The Ford assembly line was notoriously grueling, requiring monotonous, relentless physical labor that led to rapid burnout, high turnover, and costly errors. By experimenting with schedules, Ford discovered that workers operating on five-day shifts with two days of rest were significantly more productive per hour than those slogging through a six-d...

In Band of Brothers, an officer gives German prisoners a cigarette, and then you hear a machine gun fire. If he executed them, was that a common practice during World War II?

  Lieutenant Ronald Speirs never denied gunning down those prisoners. The darkest truth isn't just that the execution likely happened—it's that among D-Day paratroopers, it was tragically common. In the HBO miniseries Band of Brothers , Speirs is shown offering cigarettes to a group of captured Germans before raising a Thompson submachine gun and firing off-camera. While the show frames this as a dark rumor spreading through Easy Company, veterans of the 101st Airborne, including Major Richard Winters, widely believed the story to be true. Art DiMarzio, a soldier in Speirs' platoon, later claimed to have witnessed the execution firsthand. Recognizing the tactical value of the myth, Speirs let it persist. Cultivating a reputation as a ruthless killer made him intensely feared, which he used to command immediate, unquestioning obedience in combat. Executing prisoners, while a clear violation of the Geneva Conventions, became a grim tactical reality during the early stages of ...

What happened to Lt Col Hal Moore after the Battle of the Idrang Valley? Was he ever assigned command again?

  Surviving the brutal Battle of Ia Drang didn't earn Lt. Col. Hal Moore a ticket home. He was immediately promoted to Colonel, handed a new brigade, and sent straight back into the jungle. Commanding the 1st Cavalry Division's 3rd Brigade, he led the unit through several more major engagements in Vietnam, including Operation Binh Phu, before completing his combat tour in 1966. Upon returning to the United States, Moore steadily climbed the general officer ranks and was absolutely assigned command again. After serving at the Pentagon and earning his first star, he was promoted to Major General and took command of the 7th Infantry Division stationed in South Korea in 1970. Following his time in Korea, Moore was appointed Commanding General of the U.S. Army Training Center at Fort Ord, California. This was a critical command during a turbulent era. The Army was transitioning away from the Vietnam-era draft system and building the foundation of the modern all-volunteer force. Moor...

What makes some military leaders beloved by their troops while others are despised?

The line between a beloved military commander and a despised one rarely hinges on tactics. It comes down to who sleeps in the dirt, and who lives in a luxury villa. The Siege of Kut during World War I produced one of the most despised commanders in British military history. In 1916, Major-General Charles Townshend surrendered his garrison to the Ottoman Empire, sending over 13,000 British and Indian troops into captivity. Half of his men died of starvation, disease, and abuse during brutal death marches across the desert. Townshend refused to share their fate. As the photograph above illustrates, Townshend was treated as an honored guest rather than a prisoner of war. While his men were subjected to horrific conditions, he was escorted by boat to a luxury villa on an island near Constantinople. He kept a personal chef, enjoyed an aristocratic lifestyle, and spent his captivity writing letters complaining about his lack of a promotion. His surviving troops despised him because he viewed...

What happened to the U.S. Embassy staff in Japan after Pearl Harbor was attacked?

As news of Pearl Harbor broke in Tokyo, diplomatic immunity vanished. American staff frantically burned codebooks as Japanese police locked the gates, turning the U.S. Embassy into a prison. Ambassador Joseph C. Grew, along with his staff, their families, and a handful of American journalists, found themselves sealed inside. For the next six months, the roughly 65 internees lived under strict confinement. The Japanese government cut off all direct communication with the outside world, allowing contact only through the neutral Swiss legation. As the Japanese winter set in, fuel was strictly rationed, and food supplies dwindled, forcing the staff to survive on whatever provisions they had stockpiled. While the embassy staff endured the cold, neutral nations brokered an intricate diplomatic swap between the warring powers. Switzerland and the International Red Cross negotiated an agreement to exchange Allied diplomats and civilians trapped in Asia for Japanese diplomats and citizens inter...

Why did French knife grinders around 1900 work lying on their stomachs with dogs on their legs?

For ten hours a day, French knife grinders lay face-down over spinning stones, using gravity to save their spines. To warm their freezing, motionless legs, they used dogs. These workers in Thiers, France, known as émouleurs , produced the majority of the country's knives at the turn of the 20th century. The physical demands of the job dictated their unusual prone posture. Grinding hardened steel against fast-spinning sandstone wheels required immense, sustained pressure. If a grinder stood and hunched over the wheel, pushing down with his arms and lower back, the strain would ruin his spine in a matter of years. By lying flat on a wooden board—called a planche à ventre —suspended above the stone, the grinder could press his entire body weight into the blade. The dogs were a practical solution to a brutal environment. The workshops, or rouets , were built in the deep, shaded gorges of the Durolle river to harness the water power needed to spin the heavy stones. These stone buildings...

Did any WW2 German soldiers ever fight as mercenaries after the war?

World War II ended in 1945, BUT for thousands of German soldiers, the fighting simply moved to a new country and a new paycheck. Germany was ruined. Workplaces were few, finances were tough, and most of the veterans could do just one thing: FIGHT. France took advantage of their fighting skills straight away. The country was involved in the war in Indochina and French Foreign Legion needed trained warriors. From 1945 to 1954, up to 50,000 German veterans fought in Vietnam for the French, supporting the country which they had recently fought against. Some veterans moved to the Middle East. Egypt and Syria employed German officers, among others former SS officers, to train military personnel, form commando forces and set up intelligence services. The USA provided another option in 1950, when an act regulating foreign recruitment was passed, allowing foreigners to join the American army in order to obtain citizenship in five years. Many German and Eastern European veterans accepted it. In ...

When did Germany find out that Enigma was broken?

Although some people had suspicions, particularly Karl Dönitz the head of the Kriegsmarine, the full story of the breaking of Enigma (Ultra) was not finally revealed to the world until 1974 when The Ultra Secret was published by F.W. Winterbotham. However, other works hinting at the fact that Enigma had been broken, such as Battle for Secrets by Władysław Kozaczuk and The Codebreakers by David Kahn, had been published before that in 1967. During the war, the Germans dismissed evidence that Enigma had been broken. Indeed, Kapitän zur See Heinz Bonatz, the former head of the Kriegsmarine 's B-Dienst ( Beobachtungsdienst), part of German Naval Intelligence, asserted in his history of German naval intelligence, Die deutsche Marine Funkaufklärung 1914–1945, published in 1970, that Enigma had never been broken. Enigma decrypts (Ultra) were shared with a very small and select audience and the British went to great lengths to disguise their sources, both from their own people and from...

Is there anything France could have done differently in 1940 to stop the German invasion?

The French and British could have easily defeated Germany when the Wehrmacht invaded in 1940. Their military leadership knew what to expect because 8 months earlier they watched Poland fall to the Blitzkrieg. This gave them plenty of time to prepare and reorganize for the style of warfare they just witnessed. Instead, the Allies stuck with their plans for WW1 part deux. They spread out, dug in and the rest is history. Poland held out for 35 days while France with its large economy and military lasted 46 days. Germany accomplished this without taking significant casualties or through the use of superweapons. Their strategy and tactics were simply better than the Allies by a wide margin. It’s ironic that today many people believe that France and the UK stood almost no chance against the Germans in 1940. In reality it was the exact opposite. The important takeaway from this event is to always remember that bad leaders have a propensity to lose even when they command great teams.
  When Heath Ledger died, his two-year-old daughter wasn't named in his will. Not because he'd chosen to leave her out — but because the document had been written before she existed. Ledger signed his will in April 2003, when he was just 24. At the time, he hadn't yet met Michelle Williams, and their daughter, Matilda, wouldn't be born until October 2005. So the will did the only thing it could: it left his estate to the people who were his family then — his parents and his three sisters. Then, on January 22, 2008, Heath died suddenly at just 28. His estate was later valued at more than $16 million. And almost immediately, questions began to swirl about what would happen to Matilda, who by law hadn't been included at all. His family's answer was immediate and unwavering. His father, Kim Ledger, said Matilda was their "absolute priority," and that Michelle was an integral part of the family — both would be looked after, exactly as Heath would have wante...